SMR Knowledge

Building the Knowledge Culture

  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • About Us
    • The SMR Team
  • SMR’s Knowledge Services Blog
  • SMRShare
  • Contact SMR

Knowledge Thought Leaders: A Practical Question

November 24, 2010 By Guy St. Clair

Sergio Storch in Brazil offers an intriguing dialogue opportunity in his response to the last post about knowledge thought leaders. So intriguing, in fact, that I want to be sure the question gets thrown out to all our readers, so I’m highlighting it as a separate post.

Here’s his practical question:

In a concrete situation where you have a large organization and want to identify the KM thought leaders, which of these methods would you prefer?

a) formulate the traits of these guys and then ask the managers to tell you who in their teams fits to each of these traits of an ideal profile? Would you use a scale for that?

b) throw a bottle in the sea (in the network) and ask people at all levels to self-rate themselves?

c) the same but ask all people to tell who in their personal networks correspond to those traits?

Which pros and cons you have for each of these methods?

How would you respond to Sergio?

Tagged With: KM, KM/Knowledge Services, knowledge network analysis, knowledge networking, Knowledge Strategy, Knowledge Thought Leaders, organizational development, organizational effectiveness, organizational management, social networking

About Guy St. Clair

Guy St. Clair is the Series Editor for Knowledge Services, from Verlag Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin, the scholarly publishing house specializing in academic literature. The series subject is knowledge services, the approach to managing intellectual capital that merges information management, knowledge management (KM), and strategic learning, presenting and discussing new and innovative approaches to knowledge sharing in all fields of work.

With Barrie Levy, Guy  is the author of The Knowledge Services Handbook: A Guide for the Knowledge Strategist (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2020). He is also the author of Knowledge Services: A Strategic Framework for the 21st Century Organization (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2016). [Note: Go here for the free PDF version of this book: https://bit.ly/3msI27V. ]

Guy is also the author of Knowledge Services: Five Free Webinars from Guy St. Clair, available to anyone who wants to learn more about knowledge services. The webinars are offered at no charge.

Guy’s other professional writings are listed in SMR International’s corporate website, at SMRShare. 

Comments

  1. Ferdinand says

    November 25, 2010 at 5:25 pm

    I would not rely on any opinion. There is too much bias and politics in big companies.
    I would suggest you run a challenging test.
    Choose based on what you perceive as the best result.
    Agree that is not easy to come up with a reliable test.
    Regards

    Reply
  2. guystclair says

    November 25, 2010 at 6:08 pm

    From Jon Thorne via LinkedIn’s KM Edge Group:

    a great article … but I would not use any of the options put forward.

    For me the people with the knowledge worth capturing tend to be people who have had an experience … that is relevant to a large enough group to make it worthwhile capturing.

    This is based on the assumption that knowledge is captured in a way that it enables others about to experience a similar situation … to make better choices.

    hope this adds

    cheers jon

    GStC: Of course, Jon. And I’m surprised I let the experience “piece” slip by. It’s key to our success with KD/KS, no matter what kind of subject field we happen to be in. I happen to have on a shelf next to my desk a 1999 title, given as a birthday present a few years later. It’s The experience economy – work is theatre and every business a stage: goods and services are no longer enough, by B. Joseph Pine II and James H. Gilmore (Harvard Business School Press). I’ve dipped into this book more times than I can remember, and I always come away with the same thought: it’s experience that makes us valuable to our customers, whether we are external management consultants or internal consultants (e.g., knowledge thought leaders). Thanks for the insightful comment, Jon.

    Reply
  3. Dolly Bhasin says

    November 26, 2010 at 1:43 am

    I fully agree with John. You do not ask a thought leader to identify himself or you set YOUR parameters or YARDSTICKS to measure the traits, as CONTEXT is most IMPORTANT in thought leadership. I might be very good THOUGHT LEADER in a SUBJECT in a particular Context, but the moment the context changes, I might not measure up. However, thought leaders have one quality which can be spotted by good leaders/CEOs and COOs in an organisation if they look carefully – they work PROACTIVELY, spot problems when others do not see any, and work to find solutions and at time make sure that the problem is rectified even before it truly arises.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SMR’s Knowledge Services Blog Archives (since 2009)

Tags

archives management Conversational Leadership corporate archives corporate records COVID – 19 Healthcare Hovell (John) IAO ICT ICT training Information Africa Organization information and communications technology information management information technology KD/KS KM KM KM/Knowledge Services KM training knowledge asset management knowledge development/knowledge sharing knowledge development and knowledge sharing knowledge networking knowledge services knowledge sharing Knowledge Strategy Knowledge Thought Leaders Manion (Kevin) organizational archives organizational behavior organizational effectiveness organizational management organizational records Peter F. Drucker records management social networking Special Libraries Association strategic knowledge strategic knowledge management strategic knowledge services Strategic Learning strategic planning strategy development The Knowledge Culture ” management

Contact Information

SMR International
10 Park Avenue, Suite # 4-F
New York, NY 10016 USA

+1 917 797 1500
info@smr-knowledge.com
www.smr-knowledge.com

Follow Us

  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Recent Blog Posts

  • Five Free Knowledge Services Webinars August 1, 2022
  • KM/Knowledge Services Community: Humanist Management and Knowledge Services (Part 2) January 24, 2022
  • KM/Knowledge Services Community: Guy St. Clair on Humanist Management and Knowledge Services ( Part 1) December 28, 2021

Copyright © 2023 · SMR International · All Rights Reserved